Mietta's Review
Prams can block up this small and cosy shopfront store. It's a great meeting place for smartly dressed Carlton mums to meet for a chat, cake and coffee. But there's lots more on offer here. The sounds and smell of the kitchen are readily visible, creating an atmosphere that's a cross between a cafeteria and the kitchen of a professional chef, when he's lounging around at home. An array of comfort foods adorn the large glass counter with very little hidden from the customers' eyes. Plates, platters and large glass jars groan happily with homemade muffins, biscuits, cakes and imaginative-looking salads all piled up to create a kind of mini "wall of food". It's an impulse eater's heaven. But as well as what's on show, Ricky Holt has a tempting menu of items to be cooked to order. The Rathdowne Street Food Store is relaxed, unpretentious and friendly. Not the place to hurry through unless you are picking up takeaway.
Other published opinions
Age Good Food Guide 2009 Score: 12.5/20
Age Good Food Guide 2008 Score: 13/20
Age Good Food Guide 2006 score 13/20
Herald Sun CityStyle 26/04/05 Donna Coutts score 17/20 "All class. Tasty, wholesome food made with quality ingredients. Breakfast, lunch or dinner recommended."
Age Good Food Guide 2005
Age Cheap Eats 2004
The Foodies' Guide 2004, Allan Campion & Michele Curtis,'The Foodies' Guide Cupcake Awards 2004-our pick of the top foodies experience'
AGFG 2004, score 14/20, excellent breakfasts
Vogue Entertaining & Traveller, March April 2003,'All day breakfasts and more.'
Age, Sunday Life, 9/11/03, John Lethlean
Herald Sun, Sunday Magazine, Eating Out, Sally Fishe
Age, A2, Food & Wine, 19/7/03
Age, Sunday Life, Eat Streets, Dani Valent, 25/5/03
Cheap Eats 2003, Breakfast Dish of the Year
Age, Unexplored Territory, Matt Preston, 1/10/02
Age SundayLife 1/10/2000
Or perhaps ...
Bande Apart 9388 8950, 749 Nicholson St, Carlton North
Bar Fred 9381 0501, 797 Nicholson St, Carlton North
Bar Nothing Noir Lounge (03) 9380 2424, 16 Pigdon St, Carlton North
Birdie Num Nums (03) 9380 1950, 745 Nicholson St, Carlton North
Bistro Flor 9381 4443, , 555 Nicholson St, Carlton North - Great little wine bar with an excellent cellar, good tapas and enjoyable bistro dishes.
Brooze Restaurant (03) 9347 4284, , NULL, 649 Rathdown Street, Carlton North
The Calabrian Ristorante (03) 9347 0777, 406-408 Rathdowne St, Carlton North
Chin Chin's at Koto Moon 9349 4545, , 647 Rathdowne St, Carlton North - This comfortable neighbourhood cafe boasts "Chinatown quality in Rathdowne St".
Enoteca Vino Bar 9389 7070, 920 Lygon St, Carlton North - Enoteca Sileno's produce stall and restaurant. Beautiful product for sale and a vast range of dishes that display them.
Gerald's Bar 9349 4748, 386 Rathdowne St, Carlton North
La Luna Bistro 9349 4888, 320 Rathdowne St, Carlton North - This is a great neighbourhood restaurant. Service is good and the food is well balanced and flavoursome.
North Cafeteria 9348 1276, 717 Rathdowne St, Carlton North
Rathdowne Street Food Store (03) 9347 4064, 617 Rathdowne St, Carlton North - The sounds and smell of the kitchen are readily visible, creating an atmosphere that's a cross between a cafeteria and the kitchen of a professional chef, when he's lounging around at home.
Residential Cafe (03) 9381 2388, , 499 Lygon St, Carlton North
Thai Classic (03) 9347 3233, 507 Nicholson St, Carlton North - An oasis of warmth set in the tropics, Thai Classic is ideal for the romantic dinner.